ISSN: 2155-6105

Journal of Addiction Research & Therapy
Open Access

Our Group organises 3000+ Global Conferenceseries Events every year across USA, Europe & Asia with support from 1000 more scientific Societies and Publishes 700+ Open Access Journals which contains over 50000 eminent personalities, reputed scientists as editorial board members.

Open Access Journals gaining more Readers and Citations
700 Journals and 15,000,000 Readers Each Journal is getting 25,000+ Readers

This Readership is 10 times more when compared to other Subscription Journals (Source: Google Analytics)
  • Short Communication   
  • J Addict Res Ther 2017, Vol 8(5)
  • DOI: 10.4172/2155-6105.1000344

Fatal Alcohol Poisonings and Poisonings by Other Toxic Substances in Russia

Razvodovsky YE*
International Academy of Sobriety, , Belarus
*Corresponding Author : Razvodovsky YE, International Academy of Sobriety, Belarus, Tel: + 375 0152 70 18 84, Fax: +375 0152 43 53 41, Email: yury_razvodovsky@mail.ru

Received Date: Aug 14, 2017 / Accepted Date: Sep 25, 2017 / Published Date: Oct 02, 2017

Abstract

Background: It is widely believed that one of the negative consequences of Gorbachev’s anti-alcohol campaign in Russia in the mid-1980s was the dramatic growth in the number of deaths from poisonings by non-beverage alcohol surrogates. Objective: This paper aims to clarify this important issue by analyzing the trends in fatal alcohol poisonings and poisonings by other toxic substances in Russia between 1956 and 2005. Methods: To examine the relation between fatal alcohol poisonings and poisonings by other toxic substances trends across the study period a time series analysis was performed using the statistical package “Statistica 12. StatSoft”. Results: The alcohol poisonings mortality rates for both sexes dropped sharply between 1984 and 1988. Substantial reduction was also recorded in the number of deaths from poisonings by other toxic substances in the mid-1980s. According to the results of time-series analysis there was a positive and statistically significant association between fatal poisonings by alcohol and poisonings by other toxic substances at the population level. Conclusion: The official statistical data do not support the claims that the Gorbachev’s anti-alcohol campaign contributed to the dramatic growth in fatal poisonings by non-beverage alcohol surrogates.

Keywords: Fatal alcohol poisonings; Poisonings by other toxic substances; Mortality

Citation: Razvodovsky YE (2017) Fatal Alcohol Poisonings and Poisonings by Other Toxic Substances in Russia. J Addict Res Ther 8: 344. Doi: 10.4172/2155-6105.1000344

Copyright: © 2017 Razvodovsky YE. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited

Review summary

  1. Sergei V. Jargin
    Posted on Dec 01 2017 at 1:26 pm
    Alcohol-related poisonings in Russia: Obfuscated truth Yuri Razvodovsky asked me per e-mail to write a “friendly” letter to Editor referring to his article [1]. The original correspondence is reproduced here below after the reference list. In reply, I cited the phrase from the article: “The official statistical data do not support the claims that the… аnti-alcohol campaign contributed to the dramatic growth in fatal poisonings by non-beverage alcohol surrogates” [1] and commented that I witnessed mass poisonings e.g. with window cleaner in 1988. Poisonings with methanol and carbon tetrachloride (used e.g. in dry cleaning) were known to occur as well. Considering the large scale of the window cleaner sales in some places e.g. in Siberia, it was knowingly tolerated by authorities. During the anti-alcohol campaign (1985-1989), consumption of technical alcohol-containing liquids, lotions and self-made alcohol (samogon) was known and seen to be increased considerably [2]. Razvodovsky replied that “there are two realities: one, which we both know, and another – official statistics”. Obviously, Razvodovsky should have discussed in his article [1] the “realities we both know” i.e. common knowledge and observations; without that his paper is misleading. The above citation indicates that Razvodovsky knowingly obfuscated facts, which impedes further discussions. Doubting the data and conclusions of the article [1], I asked Razvodovsky to send me a link to the statistics used in his article. Razvodovsky did not send the link but replied that the data were partly confidential, partly available from the Russian Statistical Committee; the URL cited in the article [1]: http://www.gks.ru. There are no other references pertaining to the statistics in [1]. Using this URL, I was unable to find data corresponding to the statistics and graphs in the article [1]. If even the official data exist, they are not necessarily reliable. Statistics from the former Soviet Union generally had both meaning and significance; however, the release of information was controlled, sometimes being designed to mislead: examples of data manipulation for propaganda purposes are known; more details and references are in [3]. Scientific statistics has been manipulated as well [4,5]. For example, between 1984 and 1994, mortality rates in Russia underwent a rapid decline followed by a steep increase. The decrease in mortality and, specifically, the poisoning mortality rates [1] might have been initially overstated to highlight successes of the anti-alcohol campaign, subsequently compensated by overstated mortality figures [3]. Today, the increase in the life expectancy in Russia is apparently overstated again to emphasize successes of current healthcare policies. Therefore, behind the “huge variation in Russian mortality” [6] seems to be an artefact. Furthermore, Razvodovsky mentioned in his correspondence that he is a “military man”. Indeed, since the late 1980s, many former party, military and other functionaries as well as their protégés were introduced into educational and scientific institutions of the former Soviet Union. They used “manliness” i.e. hidden threats and intimidation not only to facilitate their own careers but also to push through prescribed ideology in the guise of scientific truth [4]. For example, phrases like “Alcohol is the biggest killer in Russia” [1] are aimed to camouflage shortages of the public healthcare shifting responsibility from authorities to patients i.e. supposedly self-inflicted diseases due to excessive alcohol consumption. Another statement: “…alcohol surrogates (industrial spirits, antiseptics, lighter fluid and medications containing alcohol) may be responsible for the extremely high level of fatal alcohol poisonings in Russia” [1] creates impression that consumers deliberately purchase surrogates for drinking. In fact, consumption of alcohol-containing technical liquids, lotions etc. decreased abruptly after the anti-alcohol campaign, when vodka, beer and other beverages have become easily available and relatively cheap. However, technical alcohol from non-edible sources (synthetic and cellulosic) has been used after the anti-alcohol campaign for production of beverages sold through legally operating shops, eateries and previously also kiosks [7,8]. Finally, Razvodovsky mentioned in his correspondence the publication pressure, forcing him to publish as much as possible. Note that science, to be truthful, must be free from all kinds of pressure. Considering the above and previously published arguments [9-12], numerous papers by Yuri Razvodovsky (spelled also Iuri Razvodovskii in the PubMed) are misleading. References 1. Razvodovsky YE (2017) Fatal Alcohol Poisonings and Poisonings by Other Toxic Substances in Russia. J Addict Res Ther 8: 344. doi: 10.4172/2155-6105.1000344 2. Jargin SV (2017) Pine tree tapping in Siberia with special reference to alcohol consumption. J Addiction Prevention 5(1): 3. 3. Jargin SV (2015) Cardiovascular mortality trends in Russia: possible mechanisms. Nat Rev Cardiol 12(12): 740. 4. Jargin SV (2013) Some aspects of medical education in Russia. Am J Med Stud 1(2): 4-7. 5. Jargin SV (2017) Scientific misconduct and related topics. Am J Exp Clin Res 4(1): 197-201. 6. Leon DA, Chenet L, Shkolnikov VM, Zakharov S, et al. (1997) Huge variation in Russian mortality rates 1984-94: artefact, alcohol, or what? Lancet 350: 383-388. 7. Jargin SV (2016) Questionable information on poisonings by alcohol surrogates. Interdiscip Toxicol 9(3-4): 83-84 8. Jargin SV (2017) Popular alcoholic beverages in Russia with special reference to quality and toxicity. J Addiction Prevention 5(2): 6. 9. Jargin SV (2016) Alcoholic beverage type and pancreatitis: A letter from Russia. Pancreas 45(5): e18-19. 10. Jargin SV (2015) Some aspects of Nonbeverage alcohol consumption in the former Soviet Union. Psychiatry J 2015: 507391. 11. Jargin SV (2016) Alcohol and alcoholism in Russia since 1985 with special reference to the suicide rate. Int J Psychiatry 1(2). 12. Jargin SV (2015) Vodka vs. fortified wine in Russia: Retrospective view. Alcohol Alcohol 50(5): 624-625. E-mail correspondence Jargin-Razvodovsky, cited in the text above. Приказывать Вам не смею по разным причинам. Основная из них - не люблю этого делать, хотя человек военный (сержант Советской Армии, в последствии - старший лейтенант медслужбы в запасе). Касательно Ваших замечаний. Здесь сталкиваются две реальности: одна - очевидцами которой мы с Вами были, а другая - данные официальной статистики. Поэтому здесь есть место для дискуссии. Что касается данных, которые я использовал. Их мне любезно предоставили коллеги на условиях конфиденциальности. Данные по алкогольным отравлениям имеются на сайте Росстата. С уважением Юрий Понедельник, 27 ноября 2017, 15:31 +02:00 от sjargin : Здравствуйте, Юрий! Вы пишете: the official statistical data do not support the claims that the аnti-alcohol campaign contributed to the dramatic growth in fatal poisonings by non-beverage alcohol surrogates. Я своими глазами видел в Сибири в 1988 г. отравленных жидкостью для мойки окон, явление, очевидно носило массовый характер. Как прикажете возражать? Юрий, не могли бы Вы прислать ссылку на использованные Вами статистические данные по алкогольным отравлениям? Заранее большое спасибо, с самыми лучшими пожеланиями, Сергей Понедельник, 27 ноября 2017, 13:55 +04:00 от Yury Razvodovsky : Здравствуйте, Сергей! Надеюсь, у Вас все нормально. Периодически с интересом читаю Ваши работы и ссылаюсь на них. Хотел отправить Вам, согласно Вашему запросу статью по отравлениям, но увидел, что Вы ее уже получили. Прошу Вас написать письмо в редакцию по этой статье (в дружеской манере), а я в такой же манере на него отвечу. На работе требуют отчитываться публикациями, так что приходится изобретать различные способы "повышения производительности труда".
Top