Global Journal of Nursing & Forensic Studies
Open Access

Nursing Ethics, Forensic Nursing, Confidentiality, Trauma-Informed Care, Legal and Ethical Dilemmas

Introduction

Forensic nursing is a specialized field that intersects healthcare and the criminal justice system. Nurses working in forensic settings often care for victims and perpetrators of violence, abuse, or criminal activities. In these environments, they face unique ethical challenges that require a thorough understanding of both nursing ethics and legal principles [1-3]. Forensic nurses are responsible for providing compassionate care while also ensuring that their medical findings and actions are legally valid and supportive of justice. This short communication outlines the key ethical issues faced by forensic nurses and underscores the importance of ethical guidelines in this complex area of practice.

Key Ethical Issues in Forensic Nursing

Confidentiality and Legal Exceptions

Confidentiality is a fundamental ethical principle in nursing practice. However, in forensic settings, nurses must navigate situations where their duty to maintain patient confidentiality is in conflict with legal obligations. Forensic nurses often need to report findings related to abuse, violence, or criminal activity. While maintaining patient trust is essential, forensic nurses must also understand when and how to breach confidentiality to comply with mandatory reporting laws. This delicate balance requires a comprehensive understanding of local laws and professional ethics [4].

Dual Role: Caregiver vs. Legal Participant

Forensic nurses are frequently required to act in dual roles: as healthcare providers and as participants in the legal process. In cases of trauma or abuse, forensic nurses not only offer medical care but also gather forensic evidence that may be crucial to legal proceedings. They may serve as expert witnesses in court, presenting findings and testifying on the medical aspects of a case. This dual responsibility can create ethical dilemmas, particularly when actions taken for legal purposes may conflict with the patient’s immediate healthcare needs. Forensic nurses must be skilled in maintaining professional boundaries and ensuring that their involvement in the legal process does not compromise patient care or their objectivity [5].

Informed Consent and Patient Autonomy

Informed consent is a cornerstone of nursing practice, especially in forensic settings where the stakes are high. Nurses must ensure that patients fully understand the procedures they will undergo, including the collection of forensic evidence, medical exams, and the potential use of this evidence in legal proceedings. Forensic nurses must also be sensitive to the vulnerability of their patients, many of whom may be victims of trauma or violence. It is essential that forensic nurses communicate clearly and ensure that patients are empowered to make informed decisions, free from coercion or fear of retaliation.

Trauma-Informed Care

Forensic nurses often work with individuals who have experienced significant trauma, and providing trauma-informed care is critical. This approach recognizes the pervasive impact of trauma on a person’s physical, emotional, and psychological well-being. Forensic nurses must be aware of the potential for traumatization during medical examinations or evidence collection and must adopt techniques that minimize harm while maximizing support. Nurses should prioritize empathy, patience, and respect for the patient’s emotional state throughout the healthcare process [6, 7].

Cultural Sensitivity and Bias

Forensic nurses may encounter patients from diverse backgrounds, and ethical practice requires an awareness of cultural differences. Nurses must be sensitive to cultural norms, beliefs, and values that may influence how patients view healthcare, trauma, and the legal system. Cultural competence is essential in ensuring that care is provided in a respectful and non-judgmental manner. Ethical dilemmas may arise if unconscious biases influence the nurse’s approach to assessment, care, or evidence collection. To mitigate this, forensic nurses should receive training in cultural competency and actively work to challenge biases in their practice [8-10].

Conclusion

Forensic nursing is a complex and multifaceted field where ethics, healthcare, and law intersect. Nurses working in forensic settings must navigate numerous ethical challenges, including confidentiality, informed consent, dual roles, and the provision of trauma-informed care. It is essential that forensic nurses understand both the legal implications of their work and the ethical principles that guide their practice. Ongoing education, clear ethical guidelines, and specialized training are vital in helping forensic nurses provide the best possible care while ensuring the integrity of the legal process. By upholding high ethical standards, forensic nurses contribute to both the well-being of their patients and the pursuit of justice.

1. Ciudadano E, El ciudadano (2015) Obtenido de 300 mil pacientes al ano puede atender el nuevo Pablo Arturo Suarez.

Indexed at, Google Scholar

2. Machado A (2004) Select Poems of Antonio Machado. En W. Barn stone. New York: Copper Canyon Press Obtenido de.

Google Scholar

3. Morales J, Yanez A, Fernandez-Gonzalez L, Montesinos-Magraner L, Marco-Ahullo A et al. (2019) Stress and autonomic response to sleep deprivation in medical residents: A comparative cross-sectional study 14:e0214858.

Indexed at, Google Scholar, Crossref

4. Schwartz L P, Hursh S R, Boyle L, Davis J E, Smith M et al. (2021) Fatigue in surgical residents an analysis of duty-hours and the effect of hypothetical naps on predicted performance. Am J Surg 221:866-871.

Indexed at, Google Scholar, Crossref

5. Vilchez-Cornejo J, Viera-Moron R D, Larico-Calla G, Alvarez-Cutipa D C, Sanchez-Vicente J C et al. (2020) Depression and abuse during medical internships in Peruvian hospitals, Duty Hour Regulations of Physicians in Training and Circadian Considerations. Circadian Rhythm Sleep-Wake Disorders ombiana de Psiquiatría. Revista Col Olson E J 49:75-82.

Indexed at, Google Scholar, Crossref

6. Fowler L A, Ellis S (2019) the effect of 12 hour shifts, time of day, and sleepiness on emotional empathy and burnout in medical students. Clocks Sleep 1:501-509.

Indexed at, Google Scholar, Crossref

7. Carrasco J P, Ferrando M, Jimenez M, Martin J, Martínez E (2021) Se sobrecarga a los médicos residentes? Estudio descriptivo sobre la falta de libranza de guardias de los médicos residentes y análisis de sus consecuencias docentes en la provincia de Valencia. Educación Medica 22:98-105.

Indexed at, Google Scholar, Crossref

8. Arteaga Gende M R (2021) Deterioro cognitivo en médicos residentes por la privación Del sueño en guardias de 24 horas. Revista San Gregorio 1:174-191.

Google Scholar, Crossref

9. Vallejo-Noguera FF, Rubio-Endara O W, Medranda-Zambrano RG (2019) Riesgos psicosociales en personal médico que labora en el Hospital Rodríguez Zambrano en Manta, Ecuador. Dominio de las Ciencias 5:4-18.

Indexed at, Google Scholar

10. Linaresa K C C, Cama L F R (2020) Persistencia del síndrome burnout en internos de medicina en hospitals de Lima Peru Investigation en educacion medica 8:9-15.

Indexed at, Google Scholar